From Ritual to Romance Jessie Laidlay Weston 9781492861614 Books
Download As PDF : From Ritual to Romance Jessie Laidlay Weston 9781492861614 Books
_feature_div" class="feature" data-feature-name="bookDescription">
From Ritual to Romance Jessie Laidlay Weston 9781492861614 Books
The book shows its age terribly: a wealth of irrelevant material and a plague of middle French quotations (untranslated, of course) which show either the author's erudition or her utter contempt for those who would read her work without knowing French (Merde!). Buy Robert Graves' White Goddess instead; or anything by Graves for that matter.Product details
|
Tags : From Ritual to Romance [Jessie Laidlay Weston] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers.,Jessie Laidlay Weston,From Ritual to Romance,Createspace,1492861618,Literature & Fiction - General
People also read other books :
- Hold for Hiker Trash eBook KA Hrycik
- Paris 1000 Piece Puzzle Galison Jessica Allen 9780735332676 Books
- Chris Pratt eBook Nicholas Voth
- Mean Streets Dark Streets Trolling for Sharks book three edition by TJ Reeder TJ Reeder Literature Fiction eBooks
- No One But You edition by Jillian Hart Contemporary Romance eBooks
From Ritual to Romance Jessie Laidlay Weston 9781492861614 Books Reviews
This book, published in 1920, was a seminal influence on both T.S. Eliot in "The Wasteland" and Ernest Hemingway in "The Sun Also Rises". Eighty years later, it's still easy to see why. Although the book is short-just over 200 pages-it is almost unbelievably wide-ranging. As she deconstructs the elements of the various versions of the tales of the Holy Grail, Ms. Weston takes the reader globetrotting and time-traveling, from Vedic India to turn of the century Africa and Japan, with stops in between in Europe and the Middle East from antiquity to her own time. She relates the Grail stories to archaic sacred kingship, fertility rituals and dances, the rites and myths of Adonis, Attis and Mithra, as well as Gnostic Christianity. If you're interested in the Grail, the history of western culture, the history of religious ideas, or the transmission of myth and ritual into literary forms, "From Ritual To Romance" is truly a revelation.
to produce some of their finest and most distinctive works. Weston's scholarly work first appeared almost 90years ago and is still inspiring readers. T.S. Eliot wrote footnotes referring readers of "The Waste Land" to this rare gem which puts "The Holy Grail" init's place, that of an important ritual that far preceded Christianity in the British Isles. John Steinbeck used it overtly in his only piece of historical fiction, "Cup of Gold," and others lined up in good company behind them. The story and its variants are fascinating and will inspire readers to revisit Frasier's Golden Bough. Sir Galahad, Sir Lancelot, King Arthur, Guinevere, the Fisher King and many others made their appearances as layer upon layer were added and peeled away from this legend spawned by people long gone (or absorbed?) from the British Islands and regions of France where the grail is said to have been secreted. Though Weston's style is British, academic, and the length of her immaculately grammatical sentences would put Faulkner to shame, the information is riveting (and makes one wonder how modern filmmakers of the Arthurian genre managed to research their stories and miss so much good stuff...).
Based on other reviews I expected great things. What I got was a book written in the 20s which has never been updated. The quotes from other works are in French or other languages without translation. There is nothing here that has not been covered by newer works in greater detail.
The formatting is rubbish. Every line of the book is broken in half. For heaven's sake this should be blindingly obvious to any reviewer. Appalling that it is allowed for sale. I shall be seeking refund. I bought the other avaiable edition - which has proper formatting.
English is NOT my mother tongue. But I have read a few boo books including the magnificent one-volume edition of The Golden Bough, which I keep reading with great pleasure and profit.
I was tempted to give one star Miss Weston's book, but no guts; I have settled on two. Here are my reasons
1. The book needs a major editing. An able editor could free the book from its deadwood and unnecessary repetitions saving perhaps some 50 pages from this Dover edition. The able editor could also apply the rules of sentence and paragraph construction to ease the reader's access to and comprehension of the topic. Although there are some few lines that are clear tot he reader, this virtue cannot be found in any single page.
2. All non-English citations should be translated into English and included in the text or in footnotes. To a reader who does not know those languages the citations are useless..
3. An appendix ought to be provided to include the names of important personages in the book.
The Dover edition itself is flawless Good paper, good print, and good binding., .
So many of the quotes and excerpts are in French, German, Latin, etc and aren't translated! I don't get it...
Because Eliot's "Waste Land" is taught in virtually every British and American lit survey course, the name "Jessie Weston" and the title "From Ritual to Romance" have become familiar to perhaps millions of readers throughout the world. However, if readers hope to get beyond the "trivial pursuit" question of the source to which Eliot was indebted and to a genuine understanding of the "Fisher King" myth, they will need to read that source for themselves. Though not a quick and accessible read, the book repays the reader's patience. Not only does it help bring Eliot's poem to life but it illuminates the poetic tradition from Chaucer to Eliot and makes more meaningful the numerous adaptations of the myth in modern culture--from David Lodge's "Small World" to Robin Williams' "The Fisher King." Not for a sophomore survey course, but definitely for any upperlevel course on Eliot or Arthurian legend.
The book shows its age terribly a wealth of irrelevant material and a plague of middle French quotations (untranslated, of course) which show either the author's erudition or her utter contempt for those who would read her work without knowing French (Merde!). Buy Robert Graves' White Goddess instead; or anything by Graves for that matter.
0 Response to "⋙ [PDF] Gratis From Ritual to Romance Jessie Laidlay Weston 9781492861614 Books"
Post a Comment